Categories: Misc / DotNet / Java / Coder / Linux / PHP Ask - La ask - La Answer

Gizmodo: Apple Needs to Face the Music, iPods Broken

via Gizmodo

The new iPods have had a slew of problems since their releasemore than any other release we can remember. From massive interface lagging (which has thankfully been fixed) to problems with video out (which Apple is still sort of working out), the iPod has officially lost its infallible grace.

And now chalk up another problem. The Nike+iPod peripheral that tracks your distance while playing music doesn't let you play music.

The irony doesn't escape us. We found the bug ourselves after ten minutes of being sure we'd gone loony, button mashing play, menu and that center thingie like no tomorrow. If you begin a workout and then choose a playlist (or any set of music), the playlist won't actually play. Users have discovered sly workarounds, like changing the sex of the inspirational Nike robo voice to get the music playing. We've found that if you have music playing before entering the Nike menu, that works just as well...assuming you don't want to change your playlist, because that's totally screwy, too.

And for what could be a quick firmware fix, the problem has bothered users for over one documented montheither the one happy user on the linked thread got lucky or we're just unlucky. Either way, it's unacceptable.

The iPod justifiably succeeded based upon a simply principle that all of our readers already know: if a device performs one important function perfectly, users will forgive a lack of other functions.

And now, without all that many new functions, we're seeing a product line slowly whither from cheaper components or shoddy software testing or general arroganceor a combination of all three.

Since Apple has smoothed out the laggy interface, the new Classic and Nano really do feel like an improvement on what had become a bloated and aging design. But when an iPod can no longer play music, we have a serious problem.

End

Thoughts?

I'm happy that some media outlet of any kind has addressed these issues. I know some users here have returned the classics because of this. The iPod is a great device, it has many iterations that are great devices, but this new batch just isn't up to par with the rest of them.
[2302 byte] By [kylo4] at [2007-11-11 21:34:00]
# 1 Re: Gizmodo: Apple Needs to Face the Music, iPods Broken
they are rushing there iPods out so fast...so theres lots of bugs
Eric Lewis at 2007-11-15 17:55:30 >
# 2 Re: Gizmodo: Apple Needs to Face the Music, iPods Broken
apple is getting sloppy and lazy
JMG at 2007-11-15 17:56:30 >
# 3 Re: Gizmodo: Apple Needs to Face the Music, iPods Broken
So does this mean your all going to be buying something else non-iPod next time around?
baggss at 2007-11-15 17:57:29 >
# 4 Re: Gizmodo: Apple Needs to Face the Music, iPods Broken
So does this mean your all going to be buying something else non-iPod next time around?

Depends on if there is anything better.

better - more advantageous or effective
perfect - being entirely without fault or defect

better != perfect
JMG at 2007-11-15 17:58:32 >
# 5 Re: Gizmodo: Apple Needs to Face the Music, iPods Broken
So does this mean your all going to be buying something else non-iPod next time around?

No, they'll just buy 5 gen refurbs and further support Apple. iTunes gets you hooked and you don't want to use anything else.
kylo4 at 2007-11-15 17:59:31 >
# 6 Re: Gizmodo: Apple Needs to Face the Music, iPods Broken
So does this mean your all going to be buying something else non-iPod next time around?I'm seriously considering it. I'm just waiting for more 80GB alternatives. If they haven't managed to clean up the Classics by then, that will weigh heavily on my decision. I'm anything but hooked on iTunes.
bdb at 2007-11-15 18:00:41 >
# 7 Re: Gizmodo: Apple Needs to Face the Music, iPods Broken
So does this mean your all going to be buying something else non-iPod next time around?

Yeah. I always do, but until 5G I always came back to the iPod. It is true what Gizmodo says about doing one thing perfectly.

Thing is, moving on from the original 5G I have not had this feeling and with the latest iteration, in comparison with what else is out there I'm not getting any iPod joy (I don't have a Touch yet). Add that to the massive irritations I've had on the computer side (I own some Macs) and for me, Apple has become something of a "Look everywhere else first" company.

It's also my opinion that the quality of everything they make has gone downhill in a big way, and I mean in relation to the rest of the competitors. While the rest have regrouped and improved, Apple has faded. Any Apple product still looks great and that does a lot to mask it, but they are not keeping on top of the build quality. Being a child of the 80's I still get a big kick out of something that's really well put together, like the old Sony days. Come to think of it, Sony still gives me a kick in that regard. With Apple nowadays, I start with minor gripes until something breaks, when I go into a rage.

I haven't tried the new Zunes, but as a music player I think the featureset of that looks more compelling to me at the moment. Especially as I use Windows Media Center heavily these days.
thedodgyguy at 2007-11-15 18:01:34 >
[an error occurred while processing this directive]
[an error occurred while processing this directive]