Well, out of a 10 I would have to give the actual case a 10.
screen protecter = 8
holster clip = 8

the reason the case got a 10 is because of its sheer design. this case didnt take away from any of the beauty from my phone, but actually added it. (GASP) I dont know why, but it makes my device look like a million dollar one. The case actually does protect it also, as i dropped my iphone minutes after i put it on (my first drop) and the phone survived (although it may have without the case) the clip that comes with it is unusable.

for the screen protecter, i have to give it an 8 or lower, because it wasnt one of the easiest screen protecters ive ever put on, (had to peel it off, wash it to get lint off, take a piece of tape, cover entire sticky side then peel off the tape.) but the screen looks protected at the end. (the only way you can notice it if its off, and you can see two tiny corners where the adheisive stayed on the other side of the peel thing), and when its on by a tiny case-mate logo in the lower right hand.

for the holster, i have to give it an 8 or better because it simply does what it is supposed to do. (hold your phone). i didnt give it higher because mine came kindoff loosely put together, but i really just had to push the fabric back onto the leather and hold it for a couple of seconds.

now for the pictures.
http://i14.tinypic.com/68j07f9