Categories: Misc / DotNet / Java / Coder / Linux / PHP Ask - La ask - La Answer

iPod out of anodised aluminium?

Gotta new iPod 20Gb a couple of weeks ago and it was bliss... ...until the damn scratches came. I know it's like a new car, you see one hairline scratch and you get ####ed. By month six, you no longer care. But I'm still in the paranoid stage, with just executing the Brushed iPod technique, and buying some plastic renewer stuff for the front of the iPod with no avail.

But I wouldn't have this problem (and many others) if Apple didn't make a product out of materials that are ideal for stationary products (iMac/eMac) but not for constant kinetic motion that my iPod is now being subjected to.

Anyways to the question. Would any of you's reckon that Apple would make the upcoming (I hope so) 4G iPod out of anodised aluminium or would they keep that style strictly for the iPod Mini?
[829 byte] By [RedstarVector] at [2007-11-9 19:41:04]
# 1 Re: iPod out of anodised aluminium?
Thats a good question. The only answer I can give you is Yes, No and Maybe. ;)

It's hard to tell WHAT Apple is going to do for the Gen 4s since they are not telling ANYBODY anything about them. I've not even heard anything on any of the Mac rumor sites talking about any new iPods anytime soon (which means they could be released tomorrow with the way Apple keeps things secret).

I think this is one of those occasions when we will all just have to wait and see how Steve surprises us this time. It will, if nothing else, be interesting. :)
baggss at 2007-11-15 14:50:22 >
# 2 Re: iPod out of anodised aluminium?
I wouldn't suggest using aluminum for the 4g iPods unless they want the case to deform as easily as the mini's.

How about using something like magnesium? Sony uses it for some of their CD players and they seem really tough and durable.
crunked22 at 2007-11-15 14:51:23 >
# 3 Re: iPod out of anodised aluminium?
i say Apple will likely use aluminum as suggested. I mean, Apple loves aluminum, PowerMac G5's, PowerBooks, iPod Minis they are all aluminum based. Aluminum is more durable than the plastic and looks extremely professional. A nice scratch-resistant iPod would make the iPod even better
IlIlIlIlIl at 2007-11-15 14:52:22 >
# 4 Re: iPod out of anodised aluminium?
Uh... scratches?....scratches? My 3G 20gb is 6 months old, gets used 3 to 5 hours EVERYday and has no scratches. My 2 yo Rio had no scratches. Both had cases! DUH! I'm really tired of the snivelin' about scratches when you're either too ____, too _____ or too poor (my sympathies) to buy a good case.
Look, ya buy a jewelbox-like MP-3 player that you know you're going to use everyday, (ya buy it partly 'cause it looks great, right?) and ... ya don't buy a case to protect it! Either buy a case, or don't c/o scratches.
Anodized aluminum is still soft. It certainly is not scratch resistant! It will deform, show dents, and show scratches even worse than the SS back and the slick plastic front we have now. Scratched anodized aluminum will look pretty crummy after a few months of daily use, unless...... unless.... you buy a case! Wow! We never thought of that!
Bottom line after the rant: If you can't/won't take care of a nice slick SS and plastic bodied player, you'll never be happy with a scratched up scuzzy looking aluminum player that'll show marks even worse. I can hear it now,"You gave how much for that?"

As usual, my 2 cents worth! ;-)
W9FIF at 2007-11-15 14:53:17 >
# 5 Re: iPod out of anodised aluminium?
Ha ha, I like a good rant, W9FIF.

My angle on the subject is along the lines of this:

Years ago, gentlemen of a certain standing carried snuff boxes, tobbacco cases and cigar cases. Mostly, these would have been made of silver plated brass, or solid silver or even gold. They would have been expensive purchases in their day, and henceforth they would have been looked after. By that I mean regularly cleaned and polished.

Now, any self respecting gent would get one of his staff to do this along with the rest of the silverware but, alas, times have changed and we don't (well most of us anyway) have the luxury of personal servants to do the cleaning. So we have to do it ourselves.

I like to think of the iPod as a modern day pocket watch - it's portable, yes, but also precious. With regular care your iPod will shine for years.
zapod at 2007-11-15 14:54:16 >
# 6 Re: iPod out of anodised aluminium?
Zapod,
Absolutely, couldn't agree more! Our pods are fashion accessories along with being the current stae of the art MP-3 device, portable digital data transfer thingey, etc., etc... ad infinitum. As such, shouldn't we at least TRY to preserve it's appearance? Cases make pefect sense to me, but.......

As usual, my 2 cents worth! ;-) Humor me, I'm old!
W9FIF at 2007-11-15 14:55:23 >
# 7 Re: iPod out of anodised aluminium?
Actually, I'd like to see a limited edition (uber expensive) iPod constructed from stainless steel with a glass or crystal front. That would be something quite special.
zapod at 2007-11-15 14:56:27 >
# 8 Re: iPod out of anodised aluminium?
The very first time I had a pod in my hot little han's, I thought it looked like some piece of womans makup gear, on steroids, of course! Idea follows suit, to a "T". Sounds good to me, trinket budget allowing, I'm up fer it!

As usual, my 2 cents worth! ;-)
W9FIF at 2007-11-15 14:57:19 >
# 9 Re: iPod out of anodised aluminium?
Originally posted by W9FIF
Uh... scratches?....scratches? My 3G 20gb is 6 months old, gets used 3 to 5 hours EVERYday and has no scratches. My 2 yo Rio had no scratches. Both had cases! DUH! I'm really tired of the snivelin' about scratches when you're either too ____, too _____ or too poor (my sympathies) to buy a good case.
Look, ya buy a jewelbox-like MP-3 player that you know you're going to use everyday, (ya buy it partly 'cause it looks great, right?) and ... ya don't buy a case to protect it! Either buy a case, or don't c/o scratches.
Anodized aluminum is still soft. It certainly is not scratch resistant! It will deform, show dents, and show scratches even worse than the SS back and the slick plastic front we have now. Scratched anodized aluminum will look pretty crummy after a few months of daily use, unless...... unless.... you buy a case! Wow! We never thought of that!
Bottom line after the rant: If you can't/won't take care of a nice slick SS and plastic bodied player, you'll never be happy with a scratched up scuzzy looking aluminum player that'll show marks even worse. I can hear it now,"You gave how much for that?"

As usual, my 2 cents worth! ;-)

Well....

1. I'm in the "almost middle income" bracket of society, so yes an iPod is a big investment for me. I'll forgive you if you don't understand that.

2. Yeah I should've bought a case WITH the iPod, but that's Apple Australia's fault for not getting some adequate accessories in the Appple Centres. I mean a week to wait for a Showcase? So yeah, the only way I can get what I want (eVo) is to order online.

3. We shouldn't really have to preserve our iPods and take em out on special occasions to show it off in it's almost new glory. I mean if Apple picked their materials right, most of us wouldn't want a case.

4. If the iPod were cheaper, I wouldn't care a damn about scratches, but like my 240Z (spent a lot of money rebuilding it), it's an expensive item that you want pristine.

But whatever, I may as well get a case to HIDE the scratches lol.
RedstarVector at 2007-11-15 14:58:28 >
# 10 Re: iPod out of anodised aluminium?
"3. We shouldn't really have to preserve our iPods and take em out on special occasions to show it off in it's almost new glory. I mean if Apple picked their materials right, most of us wouldn't want a case."

I totally agree with that statement! The next iPod's should atleast be made out of scratch resistant plastic/metal (if such things even exist):confused:
crunked22 at 2007-11-15 14:59:29 >
# 11 Re: iPod out of anodised aluminium?
I think they will keep the white front, metal back thing..

HOWEVER, i believe they will try and use a different type of plastic (normal plastic) which dosen't scratch so easily.
Calculus at 2007-11-15 15:00:22 >
# 12 Re: iPod out of anodised aluminium?
I hope Calc is right.
Nicholas at 2007-11-15 15:01:31 >
# 13 Re: iPod out of anodised aluminium?
If they hard anodized, like calphalon pans, an aluminum case it wouldn't get any scratches. Biggest problem is it basicly comes in two colors gray or black. I've used on a lot of the products I've designed. You can take a file to it and it won't scratch.
Podkayne at 2007-11-15 15:02:27 >
# 14 Re: iPod out of anodised aluminium?
I rather like the idea of making modern things out of wood. You could have a iPod with a rosewood casing. Not scratch resistant, I know, but imagine the hours of pleasure you could have just polishing the thing........

I'll get me coat, then...
zapod at 2007-11-15 15:03:33 >
# 15 Re: iPod out of anodised aluminium?
Wood eh? Could be an interesting idea. If done properly a woodgrain look (not real wood of course) could look classy. Or maybe a car edition woodgrain iPod to match a nice luxury car (not that I have one or anything)!
It's just a thought though, maybe it would look horrible.

Seriously though I think the iPod metal back/plastic front looks great but, as many people have already said, it is prone to fingerprints and scratches easily. Mine sometimes even starts to feel slimey after a while! The mini-style metal seems to be much better with these things and still looks alright.
On the issue of the aluminium bending easily can't they make it slightly thicker, or put some more rigid spacers on the inside to stop it flexing as much?
someone_162 at 2007-11-15 15:04:26 >
# 16 Re: iPod out of anodised aluminium?
Hey i would be open to a carbon fibre casing haha! Most products in black tho kinda look cheap and flimsy but I think Apple could pull it off.

But yeah I think the look of the iPod is fantastic, but the plastic layer is the culprit of all the scratches. It is easily nicked and scratched and whats worse the plastic layer makes a shadow of the scratch. So does anyone know of some strong (and scratch-proof) resin plastic that Apple SHOULD use?

Either Apple didn't do their research or they did it on purpose to entice us to constantly upgrade to the next model lol.
RedstarVector at 2007-11-15 15:05:30 >
[an error occurred while processing this directive]
[an error occurred while processing this directive]