Categories: Misc / DotNet / Java / Coder / Linux / PHP Ask - La ask - La Answer

Is the iPhone a True Mac in your Pocket?

Steve says the iPhone is using OS X, but no where in the Keynote does Steve say that the iPhone can play ALL, ANY or MANY of the thousands of Mac Apps currently available. Many folks seem to think the iPhone is using a stripped down version of OS X and IMO, they may be right and the answer is really not clear.

If it were truly using standard OS X (or a superset and enhanced version of OS X) that would be just great and would more than justify the price. But there were no comments regarding "it's an iPod PLUS a true Mac in your pocket", or comments indicating compatibility with the thousands of existing Mac applications. While you might assume all of that just from the OS X claim, the marketing value of SAYING those things EXPLICITLY seems to be much too great for him to have left them out, if true. Notice how none of the press coverage refers to those advantages either. IMO it wouldn't be like Steve to fail to hawk such a tremendous advantage.

It seems more likely to be to OS X what windows mobile is to windows. (better in many ways, but with far fewer available applications). I'd love to be wrong and discover that it's a true OS X.

Isn't this the big question about the iPhone that no one seems to be asking? Any thoughts?

Pete
[1313 byte] By [Pete_L_P] at [2007-11-11 15:31:38]
# 1 Re: Is the iPhone a True Mac in your Pocket?
I don't think there is any way it could be running a full version of OSX. A portable device like that couldn't manage it.

It's most likely like windows mobile.
TheJosher at 2007-11-15 13:00:23 >
# 2 Re: Is the iPhone a True Mac in your Pocket?
That's very probably true.

OTOH most of us were truly amazed when apple squeezed so much of a true iPod into a device as small as the first generation Nano when IT was first introduced. And OQO has come fairly close (with win XP) while including a full hard drive inside.

If it IS a win mobile like device doesn't the OS X claim sound like a misrepresentation? Something akin to microsoft calling windows mobile "Windows XP"? If MS put out a device which they claimed ran windows XP, wouldn't we all correctly interpret that as meaning it runs all win XP apps?

Pete
Pete_L_P at 2007-11-15 13:01:24 >
# 3 Re: Is the iPhone a True Mac in your Pocket?
The "home" screen certainly seemed unbalanced for a device if you couldn't add any applications to it. I was surprised he didn't mention any "desktop" applications running on the iPhone too, I suspect part of the problem may be lack of storage space. 8GB is not much.

Frankly I am a little surprised there was no support for removable media to expand the device.
SimonStern at 2007-11-15 13:02:35 >
# 4 Re: Is the iPhone a True Mac in your Pocket?
I'm assuming it won't run Logic Pro...:D
alpha80 at 2007-11-15 13:03:30 >
[an error occurred while processing this directive]
[an error occurred while processing this directive]