Categories: Misc / DotNet / Java / Coder / Linux / PHP Ask - La ask - La Answer

school banns ipod

has your school ever banned the ipod because of something you yourself did or someone else in your classes did,my school did because 15 people started bringing them i did before everyone else and none of the teachers cared, since everyone did, theyre banned now i think the high school im gonna be at in august has banned them too
[330 byte] By [musiclover92] at [2007-11-11 9:18:40]
# 1 Re: school banns ipod
You're in school to learn and to become properly socialized. You don't need your iPod for that. And judging from the fact that you mispelled "bans," you could benefit from paying more attention.
MellowTone41 at 2007-11-15 15:12:13 >
# 2 Re: school banns ipod
the misspelling was a typo my keyboard is a little too responsive, and our school doesn't teach, in every class but woodshop and band, they say "shut up, sit down, and do your work, due tommorow", the teachers don't even teach, a lot of them resigned too, i finish with work in class with half the class left, i need something to do
musiclover92 at 2007-11-15 15:13:12 >
# 3 Re: school banns ipod
I would have no problem with a HS banning ipods from the grounds or at least from possession during school hours [you can leave it in your car], although to be consistent they should include things like PSPs and gameboys [which may already be banned]. Of course, I also support school uniforms/standard dress codes.
Now, the fact that the teacher's don't, won't, or can't teach, that's a whole other issue, and a saddening one at that.
dtcarson at 2007-11-15 15:14:11 >
# 4 Re: school banns ipod
Here, in Denmark, where I'm from, kids in high school, like me have a high level of freedom, and high level of responsebility. This means that you can do with your iPod what you want when you want it. However noone uses the during classes as it is considered a sign of disrespect, and it will impact your grades, naturally. And this is regular public schools.

It might change who knows, but for now they're alright.
maddMorten at 2007-11-15 15:15:18 >
# 5 Re: school banns ipod
everyone here, until they banned it, used it in breaks and lunch time and after school, i don't know why they wanted to ban it though
musiclover92 at 2007-11-15 15:16:17 >
# 6 Re: school banns ipod
Here, in Denmark, where I'm from, kids in high school, like me have a high level of freedom, and high level of responsebility. This means that you can do with your iPod what you want when you want it. However noone uses the during classes as it is considered a sign of disrespect, and it will impact your grades, naturally. And this is regular public schools.
If only the schools in North American society had that sort of attitude, it probably wouldn't be an issue.

My wife is a high school teacher, and the problem here is that kids will try listen to their iPods in class instead of doing their work, and ultimately get a failing grade. Then the parents come in and complain that it is the teacher's fault that they are not "motivating" the student. Of course, it doesn't stop at iPods, but rather seems to affect every aspect of their education... If they don't hand in an assignment on time, it must be somebody else's fault.

I'm a firm believe in encouraging personal responsibility. However, one needs the support of the whole community for that to work. When the parents themselves aren't willing to admit that their son/daughter should take responsibility for their actions, then we have a problem.
jhollington at 2007-11-15 15:17:16 >
# 7 Re: school banns ipod
I am a teacher as well, and I see this EVERYDAY at my middle school. I work in a very elite district and every kid either has an iPod, Crackberry, or personal gaming system. Our kids aren't using them during school too much, they have quite a bit of freedom here and they respect the rules, but after school, it's like a free-for-all. Our biggest problem is the expensive stuff getting stolen.
jimmyv13 at 2007-11-15 15:18:20 >
# 8 Re: school banns ipod
everyone here, until they banned it, used it in breaks and lunch time and after school, i don't know why they wanted to ban it though
Maybe they wanted you to actually socialize with eachother.
MellowTone41 at 2007-11-15 15:19:23 >
# 9 Re: school banns ipod
I was about to say--'respect'? In a US school? Never the twain shall meet. If there were a basic level of courtesy and respect in US society, much less school, it might not be as much an issue.
dtcarson at 2007-11-15 15:20:20 >
# 10 Re: school banns ipod
If only the schools in North American society had that sort of attitude, it probably wouldn't be an issue.

My wife is a high school teacher, and the problem here is that kids will try listen to their iPods in class instead of doing their work, and ultimately get a failing grade. Then the parents come in and complain that it is the teacher's fault that they are not "motivating" the student. Of course, it doesn't stop at iPods, but rather seems to affect every aspect of their education... If they don't hand in an assignment on time, it must be somebody else's fault.

I'm a firm believe in encouraging personal responsibility. However, one needs the support of the whole community for that to work. When the parents themselves aren't willing to admit that their son/daughter should take responsibility for their actions, then we have a problem.

This "freedom with responsebility" however works because it extends to all parts of society and situations, permitting people from ages 16 and up, to buy alcohol and tobacco, and get hammered twice every weekend (and they often do) There are certainly drawbacks with this kind of society. (Danish youth is in the top three, in alcohol consumption amongst young people). And I do agree with other poster saying that it will probably never happen in North American societies. How ours is turning in to a nanny-state, as such I will not be surprised the day iPods are banned in school here...sadly.
maddMorten at 2007-11-15 15:21:18 >
# 11 Re: school banns ipod
well my school (I finish my final exams and leave in 8 school days :D), has pretty much banned ipods and all other sort of electronic equipment, phones, gaming systems etc. But then again my school is a little rought round the edges and they were used in lessons and some idiot may occasionally put one on now, if the teacher's a pushover. But no-one really pays attention, Iv'e took mine in before for break etc, the teacher will tell us to put it away if they see it, but it usually comes straight back out
Jht at 2007-11-15 15:22:16 >
# 12 Re: school banns ipod
Heck, I see people listening to their iPods, playing with their cell phones, and drinking soda in my school. Keep in mind that I'm in Middle School.

Nate
Nader172 at 2007-11-15 15:23:25 >
# 13 Re: school banns ipod
I attended a public high school in the City for one semester, and you were not allowed to bring cell phones, DAP's, and handhelds into school, period (quite a few people brought them in anyway, and just never took them out; they are not allowed to search your stuff). If a teacher or other school official saw you using, even in the halls, they would just be confiscated.
Amelie at 2007-11-15 15:24:20 >
# 14 Re: school banns ipod
If only the schools in North American society had that sort of attitude, it probably wouldn't be an issue.

My wife is a high school teacher, and the problem here is that kids will try listen to their iPods in class instead of doing their work, and ultimately get a failing grade. Then the parents come in and complain that it is the teacher's fault that they are not "motivating" the student. Of course, it doesn't stop at iPods, but rather seems to affect every aspect of their education... If they don't hand in an assignment on time, it must be somebody else's fault.

I'm a firm believe in encouraging personal responsibility. However, one needs the support of the whole community for that to work. When the parents themselves aren't willing to admit that their son/daughter should take responsibility for their actions, then we have a problem.

I agree entirely with you here. The school has a role to step in when the attention of the student is diverted. Pity for those who can observe it though.
Kristiano at 2007-11-15 15:25:26 >
# 15 Re: school banns ipod
Maybe they wanted you to actually socialize with eachother.

we multitask here, well girls do anyway, i don't yet, wait, i play guitar and listen to music or drums or piano
musiclover92 at 2007-11-15 15:26:30 >
# 16 Re: school banns ipod
My wife is a high school teacher, and the problem here is that kids will try listen to their iPods in class instead of doing their work, and ultimately get a failing grade. Then the parents come in and complain that it is the teacher's fault that they are not "motivating" the student. Of course, it doesn't stop at iPods, but rather seems to affect every aspect of their education... If they don't hand in an assignment on time, it must be somebody else's fault.
Are those the *exact* same parents that b.itch a teacher out for taking away a kid's iPod?

Ugh, I can't stand parents like that. I think they abuse their kids by making excuses for them. And it ruins society, because all those kids will know is how to suckle off mommy and daddy's retirement fund. When mommy and daddy die, they'll just be deadbeats in society. Except for some of them; they'll learn how to get a job and pay money just to exist. All the same, that's a rather harsh wake up, hence why I feel this form of parenting is abusive; as it hurts the child more than anything else (not to mention society as well).

Who's going to hire you when you're 50, you've never had a job, and your sole skill is suckling other people's money? Or, if you have had jobs, and you got fired from them because you didn't do any work.
nvr-brkn at 2007-11-15 15:27:25 >
# 17 Re: school banns ipod
Ouch..my school they let you use phones and ipods in the halls, but once your in the classroom ya can't use them.
poopymath at 2007-11-15 15:28:22 >
[an error occurred while processing this directive]
[an error occurred while processing this directive]