Categories: Misc / DotNet / Java / Coder / Linux / PHP Ask - La ask - La Answer

NEW Toshiba HD Mp3 Player

http://www.toshiba.co.jp/mobileav/g20ss/
They are revealing new specs/info about it every week.
Less than 13 mm in height, wow even smaller than the ipod!
[172 byte] By [shoryuken] at [2007-11-9 13:10:42]
# 1 Re: NEW Toshiba HD Mp3 Player
Is it just me, or does that look like a Nomad Zen, but just thinner? Of course, it's not possible to see if it is *exactly* like it, but it's still similar to the Zen (IMHO).
KKo88 at 2007-11-15 14:15:30 >
# 2 Re: NEW Toshiba HD Mp3 Player
500 CD that mustt be equal to roughly 30gig.
since it is toshiba I suppose that they must use their own HD, so I would expect something of the size of the ipod (as long as they don't screw up like their previous HD mp3 player)
breadbox at 2007-11-15 14:16:31 >
# 3 Re: NEW Toshiba HD Mp3 Player
Im gunna guess that the "10?" will be 10 Hour Battery Life
shoryuken at 2007-11-15 14:17:29 >
# 4 Re: NEW Toshiba HD Mp3 Player
All that hype won't help Toshiba sell more units. People are just going to get tired of waiting for "surprises". Then again, Toshiba supplies the hard drives for iPods, so I'll just shut up.
ZoidbergD at 2007-11-15 14:18:34 >
# 5 Re: NEW Toshiba HD Mp3 Player
Anyone know japanese wanna translate for us? :)
shoryuken at 2007-11-15 14:19:33 >
# 6 Re: NEW Toshiba HD Mp3 Player
Here we go: it's not that interesting, really :P Seems like more marketing speak to me ;)

According to the newest information on the G20SS concept, inside the compact body of this audio player in development lies an incredibly high capacity drive. In terms of CDs, it would hold 500, and in terms of songs, you can store 5000. So it's not just small (in size). The full story on the large-scale G20SS concept is gradually coming to light. The next installment will appear on 12/8.
jogloran at 2007-11-15 14:20:32 >
# 7 Re: NEW Toshiba HD Mp3 Player
Well the screen looks quite small on that player. Deinitely smaller than the iPod screen. I really like the iPods big screen...
sparks9 at 2007-11-15 14:21:29 >
# 8 Re: NEW Toshiba HD Mp3 Player
are there any clear pictures of this mp3 player?
Huntyz at 2007-11-15 14:22:32 >
# 9 Re: NEW Toshiba HD Mp3 Player
I've heard it only uses 5Gig and that it can only connect through PcMcia slot of laptops. Most Destops don't have that.
chinieman2002 at 2007-11-15 14:23:40 >
# 10 Re: NEW Toshiba HD Mp3 Player
And i also think that it's 500 cd containing 1 song each. It would make sens considering a 5Gig HDD
chinieman2002 at 2007-11-15 14:24:41 >
# 11 Re: NEW Toshiba HD Mp3 Player
Haha chinieman2002... I doubt Toshiba would be that stupid, PCMCIA?? 5GB?? 1 SONG PER CD? where have you heard all of this? From your butt? :)

Im gunna guess that it will be 20GB since it is called the "G20SS"
shoryuken at 2007-11-15 14:25:40 >
# 12 Re: NEW Toshiba HD Mp3 Player
Originally posted by chinieman2002
I've heard it only uses 5Gig and that it can only connect through PcMcia slot of laptops. Most Destops don't have that.

Toshiba has made such a player, but I think it was a couple (or one) years ago...
This is a hole new (and probably better) mp3player.
I think too that it will have atleast 20 gigs of space (maybe even 30 or 40) (yeah 20 seems most likely because of the name.
sparks9 at 2007-11-15 14:26:38 >
# 13 Re: NEW Toshiba HD Mp3 Player
Originally posted by chinieman2002
I've heard it only uses 5Gig and that it can only connect through PcMcia slot of laptops. Most Destops don't have that.

you're an idiot, if it's 13mm tall, it would be about 10x too tall for a pcmcia slot
dyne at 2007-11-15 14:27:45 >
# 14 Re: NEW Toshiba HD Mp3 Player
Yep, their old player was 5Gb, here it is:

http://www.tacp.toshiba.com/digitalaudio/product.asp?model=MEG50AS
Mudskipper at 2007-11-15 14:28:40 >
# 15 Re: NEW Toshiba HD Mp3 Player
well..the maker of ipod and iriver's harddrive IS toshiba, so i wouldnt be suprised if it come out to be greater then 30g
profingersk8er at 2007-11-15 14:29:41 >
# 16 Re: NEW Toshiba HD Mp3 Player
Don't think it will affect even the ipod sales.

IPOD its IPOD
musicroom at 2007-11-15 14:30:46 >
# 17 Re: NEW Toshiba HD Mp3 Player
Originally posted by shoryuken
Haha chinieman2002... I doubt Toshiba would be that stupid, PCMCIA?? 5GB?? 1 SONG PER CD? where have you heard all of this? From your butt? :)

Im gunna guess that it will be 20GB since it is called the "G20SS"

Guess i was wrong. I must of been thinking of the old on because i thought it was the same one.

And the worst part is that i might get that one over the ipod since now i know it's a 20gig and nnot cheap 5
chinieman2002 at 2007-11-15 14:31:43 >
# 18 Re: NEW Toshiba HD Mp3 Player
Lets hope toshiba learned that consumers do not like encryption software.

BTW dyne, you are the idiot. If the design of the new player is like their first one, the player (obviously) would not go into the pcmcia slot. In their first player, the harddrive was slot-loading and when ejected, it fitted into a pcmcia slot.
MadDog5145 at 2007-11-15 14:32:48 >
# 19 Re: NEW Toshiba HD Mp3 Player
Sry, it's not like i really care about every single mp3 player in existence
chinieman2002 at 2007-11-15 14:33:46 >
# 20 Re: NEW Toshiba HD Mp3 Player
Originally posted by chinieman2002
Sry, it's not like i really care about every single mp3 player in existence but i bet you most of us would rather jump on better/newer units, when two players has basically same purpuse, they were ofter being compared to test out which one is better
profingersk8er at 2007-11-15 14:34:48 >
# 21 Re: NEW Toshiba HD Mp3 Player
Originally posted by MadDog5145
Lets hope toshiba learned that consumers do not like encryption software.

BTW dyne, you are the idiot. If the design of the new player is like their first one, the player (obviously) would not go into the pcmcia slot. In their first player, the harddrive was slot-loading and when ejected, it fitted into a pcmcia slot.

my bad, I didnt know they had a previous hdd based mp3 player, let alone one that came with an ejectable hdd
dyne at 2007-11-15 14:35:43 >
# 22 Re: NEW Toshiba HD Mp3 Player
At least now we all know that there's a new Toshiba Mp3 Player on the block
chinieman2002 at 2007-11-15 14:36:45 >
# 23 Re: NEW Toshiba HD Mp3 Player
Seems like toshiba and all the other companies r frgetting that ease of use is a factor when u r dealing w/ 5000 songs or w/e. Apple jumped ahead w/ the wheel idea.. Now that i have used it, i couldnt see myself using n e thing else.. not even a scroll the wheel's functionality amazes me..

-Ryan
RhinoBHS at 2007-11-15 14:37:46 >
# 24 Re: NEW Toshiba HD Mp3 Player
for those of you that are intersted about this player's HDD size, there is a little clue at that page with 500 CD ad, but it's in japanese

well...im chinese (and can also read/write chinese), and since almost half of japanese letters are from chinese, i can read half of it...
on that page about the music size, it says something like this:
"WMA/MP3 format, 128kbps, each song 4 minutes long, 10 songs in each CD"

so that means 5000 songs at either WMA/MP3 at 128kbps, so a good 4MB per song, 4MB x 5000 = 20,000MB...20gig...
profingersk8er at 2007-11-15 14:38:56 >
# 25 Re: NEW Toshiba HD Mp3 Player
Personally, I think it looks pretty promising. And Toshiba should be able to keep it pretty cheap since they make their own hard drives and the hard drive is a good chunk of the cost of a hard-drive based mp3 player. I also agree with RhinoBHS that nothing can come close to the iPod's touchwheel and if they steal that idea outright, they better be prepared for a long lawsuit.
tonicboy at 2007-11-15 14:39:51 >
# 26 Re: NEW Toshiba HD Mp3 Player
The only thing left that i wanted to know is what kind of HDD will it use? 2.5" or 1.8"
chinieman2002 at 2007-11-15 14:40:51 >
# 27 Re: NEW Toshiba HD Mp3 Player
Originally posted by chinieman2002
The only thing left that i wanted to know is what kind of HDD will it use? 2.5" or 1.8" I would assume it would be the 1.8" if it's only 13mm.
tonicboy at 2007-11-15 14:41:57 >
# 28 Re: NEW Toshiba HD Mp3 Player
Wonder when it's gonna be release in North America
chinieman2002 at 2007-11-15 14:42:50 >
# 29 Re: NEW Toshiba HD Mp3 Player
Originally posted by tonicboy
Personally, I think it looks pretty promising. And Toshiba should be able to keep it pretty cheap since they make their own hard drives and the hard drive is a good chunk of the cost of a hard-drive based mp3 player. I also agree with RhinoBHS that nothing can come close to the iPod's touchwheel and if they steal that idea outright, they better be prepared for a long lawsuit.
I don't see why they can't put a touchwheel on their player.
I mean, Apple didn't copyright the idea of a touchwheel. [or did they?]
Squibbles at 2007-11-15 14:43:56 >
# 30 Re: NEW Toshiba HD Mp3 Player
Originally posted by Squibbles
I don't see why they can't put a touchwheel on their player.
I mean, Apple didn't copyright the idea of a touchwheel. [or did they?] I don't mean to imply one way or another if Apple has a legal leg to stand on, but they have a long and sordid history of suing people for imitating successful Apple designs. Examples: MacOS, iMac, iPod (has already been litigated, can't remember the details but the other company backed off and redesigned their product).

Anyway, if someone puts a touchwheel on their mp3 player, it will still have to have an LCD roughly the size of the iPod's. They have to keep the basic form factor (because a rectangular device is the most compact size to fit a hard drive), in which case an LCD and a touchwheel can only be arranged so many ways and just about any arrangement will look like the iPod. The only way they can differentiate is by the buttons. Now, the buttons themselves will be pretty useless unless they put them on the face of the device for easy one-handed operation. In that case, Apple has already done two possible button layouts - circular around the touchwheel, and in a line above it. Again, they would be limited in how they can arrange the buttons. Bottom line, there aren't that many ways to design a device with an LCD, a touchwheel, and buttons on the face and the result is likely to look enough like the iPod that Apple will sue. Even if they have a good case, not many companies have the deep pockets to withstand a legal onslaught from Apple.
tonicboy at 2007-11-15 14:44:58 >
# 31 Re: NEW Toshiba HD Mp3 Player
Does anyone think Sony has got a HD player in development?

Seems the next logical step on from the 256mb NWMS70. They're still making minidisc portables but have surely conceded that they're losing more and more sales to Apple and Creative.

I think they're the only company that could match Apple in terms of aesthetics and useability. Well, apart from it probably using their Atrac system. :rolleyes: :)
Mudskipper at 2007-11-15 14:45:59 >
# 32 Re: NEW Toshiba HD Mp3 Player
Originally posted by tonicboy
Bottom line, there aren't that many ways to design a device with an LCD, a touchwheel, and buttons on the face and the result is likely to look enough like the iPod that Apple will sue. Even if they have a good case, not many companies have the deep pockets to withstand a legal onslaught from Apple. [/B]

I think the company that Apple was threatening with litigation was Samsung. Samsung backed down, but it's not necessarily because its pockets aren't as deep as Apple's (Samsung is a much larger company than Apple in nearly every conceivable way), but probably because Apple could get an injunction blocking the product from being released, and at that point, it's not a matter of who has more money since whatever the outcome, it'll take time to arrive at. The same with Toshiba. They're much, much larger than Apple, but it's probably not a fight worth fighting considering the short product cycles for mp3 players.

And to the other poster with the Sony theory, it's been pretty well established that Sony will not release anything like the iPod because of the simple fact that they own a record label. If they do release a hard drive based mp3 player, it'll be a lot closer to Toshiba's disappointingly DRM-crippled first unit than the iPod.
bamoidooki at 2007-11-15 14:47:02 >
# 33 Re: NEW Toshiba HD Mp3 Player
Originally posted by Mudskipper
Does anyone think Sony has got a HD player in development?

Seems the next logical step on from the 256mb NWMS70. They're still making minidisc portables but have surely conceded that they're losing more and more sales to Apple and Creative.

I think they're the only company that could match Apple in terms of aesthetics and useability. Well, apart from it probably using their Atrac system. :rolleyes: :)

Don't think so... Sony will probably keep using their memory sticks.
sparks9 at 2007-11-15 14:47:58 >
# 34 Re: NEW Toshiba HD Mp3 Player
Sony will only keep on using memory sticks because the invented it.
And if they started using someone elses media's, they'll be losing even more money. But they haven't realeased a new mp3 player in a while except for md's which suck.
chinieman2002 at 2007-11-15 14:49:02 >
# 35 Re: NEW Toshiba HD Mp3 Player
Then they'll be left behind.

I hear they're just introducing 'Memory Stick Pro' in 256Mb, 512Mb and 1Gb sizes. And the 1Gb stick costs.....

$450! :eek: :D

And I don't think they're compatible with their current 'network walkman' models anyway. Though I stand to be corrected.
Mudskipper at 2007-11-15 14:50:07 >
# 36 Re: NEW Toshiba HD Mp3 Player
I don't know why Sony even bothers to make their users use their Memory sticks... they are much more expenive than CF, SM, or SD, and seem to offer no advantages. The reason why I don't buy Sony digital cameras nowadays is the fact that the only media that I can use is MS.
sraphim at 2007-11-15 14:51:09 >
# 37 Re: NEW Toshiba HD Mp3 Player
The memory sticks look so much better. ;)
Squibbles at 2007-11-15 14:52:01 >
# 38 Re: NEW Toshiba HD Mp3 Player
You can buy 30 gigs worth of memory sticks for only $13,500. Who says the iPod isn't a bargin? :)
BigIzz at 2007-11-15 14:53:05 >
# 39 Re: NEW Toshiba HD Mp3 Player
Originally posted by Mudskipper
Then they'll be left behind.

I hear they're just introducing 'Memory Stick Pro' in 256Mb, 512Mb and 1Gb sizes. And the 1Gb stick costs.....

$450! :eek: :D

And I don't think they're compatible with their current 'network walkman' models anyway. Though I stand to be corrected.

Actually, they've been out for a while, maybe not 512, and 1gig, but they are out.

Even though, CF is much better and sandisk is introducing a 2gig and 4 gig model soon, don't remember exactly wheb though. And i can get CF 1gig, for around 400$ CDN (roughly 286$USD).
chinieman2002 at 2007-11-15 14:54:02 >
# 40 Re: NEW Toshiba HD Mp3 Player
There are drawbacks to harddrive based mp3 players though guys, keep that in mind. With digital memory sticks you have the whole "no moving parts" deal, which is definitley a plus over the harddrive based players. the cost difference is quite big at the moment, which is why you're seeing the emergence of the hdd based players, but i'm very sure that you'll see some big jumps in flash memory based players once the technology catches up.

with the flash cards, there's no spinning up or down the harddrive, no lagging waiting for the disk, which is a big complaint (from what i've been hearing) about the ipod. also, harddrives need power to spin, digital cards don't need as much power, so you can expect longer battery life (although they usually trade off with bright backlights and fancy stuff like that).

my ipod is just dandy, i'm not complaining. i'm just pointing out that there is a definite advantage to the digital memory.
sandeep at 2007-11-15 14:55:10 >
# 41 Re: NEW Toshiba HD Mp3 Player
The downside is that there's no playlisrt support
chinieman2002 at 2007-11-15 14:56:14 >
# 42 Re: NEW Toshiba HD Mp3 Player
Originally posted by chinieman2002
The downside is that there's no playlisrt support are you talking about solid-state mp3 players?
if you are, im sure they can just simply scrip their players to support .m3u
profingersk8er at 2007-11-15 14:57:09 >
# 43 Re: NEW Toshiba HD Mp3 Player
that thing looks strikingly similar to the ipod and uses the general HD idea of the ipod. However, the ipod's mass storage is largely what contributed to it's success. 5gb for $400 is just not worth it. Why would Toshiba go and make their own HD based Mp3 player after they are already making millions from the ipod's success??
deftdrummer1 at 2007-11-15 14:58:14 >
# 44 Re: NEW Toshiba HD Mp3 Player
Originally posted by deftdrummer1
that thing looks strikingly similar to the ipod and uses the general HD idea of the ipod. However, the ipod's mass storage is largely what contributed to it's success. 5gb for $400 is just not worth it. Why would Toshiba go and make their own HD based Mp3 player after they are already making millions from the ipod's success?? Uhhh, which device are you looking at? Because the one the rest of us are looking at is most likely 20GB with an unannounced price. And the logic for making their own is simple: cut out the middleman (Apple) and make more profits.
tonicboy at 2007-11-15 14:59:08 >
# 45 Re: NEW Toshiba HD Mp3 Player
Originally posted by deftdrummer1
that thing looks strikingly similar to the ipod and uses the general HD idea of the ipod. However, the ipod's mass storage is largely what contributed to it's success. 5gb for $400 is just not worth it. Why would Toshiba go and make their own HD based Mp3 player after they are already making millions from the ipod's success??

I think Toshiba is gonna stop supplying iPod in 4th gen. And iPods r gonna start using the ones of LaCies if they have.
chinieman2002 at 2007-11-15 15:00:11 >
# 46 Re: NEW Toshiba HD Mp3 Player
Originally posted by chinieman2002
I think Toshiba is gonna stop supplying iPod in 4th gen. And iPods r gonna start using the ones of LaCies if they have. That would be an incredibly bad move on their part. A smaller piece of a really big pie (the iPod), is a lot better than the entire piece of a potentially tiny pie (Toshiba's own player). Are you just guessing here? Where did you get this rumor from?
tonicboy at 2007-11-15 15:01:10 >
# 47 Re: NEW Toshiba HD Mp3 Player
Originally posted by tonicboy
That would be an incredibly bad move on their part. A smaller piece of a really big pie (the iPod), is a lot better than the entire piece of a potentially tiny pie (Toshiba's own player). Are you just guessing here? Where did you get this rumor from? ipod is not the only HDD player that uses toshiba'z drives, iriver also uses toshiba's HDDs
profingersk8er at 2007-11-15 15:02:18 >
# 48 Re: NEW Toshiba HD Mp3 Player
Originally posted by profingersk8er
ipod is not the only HDD player that uses toshiba'z drives, iriver also uses toshiba's HDDs Agreed. The point was that it would be foolish for them to stop supplying Apple with hard drives, ostensibly to increase sales of their own HDD-based player. I'm not sure what that has to do with the iRiver.
tonicboy at 2007-11-15 15:03:20 >
# 49 Re: NEW Toshiba HD Mp3 Player
Originally posted by tonicboy
Are you just guessing here? Where did you get this rumor from?

I think = I guess

Hopefully they wouldn't because LaCie HDD r sort of pricey
chinieman2002 at 2007-11-15 15:04:13 >
# 50 Re: NEW Toshiba HD Mp3 Player
Originally posted by tonicboy
That would be an incredibly bad move on their part. A smaller piece of a really big pie (the iPod), is a lot better than the entire piece of a potentially tiny pie (Toshiba's own player). Are you just guessing here? Where did you get this rumor from?

agreed. Besides, the basic rule of business is if you can flood the market with your product, do it. I guess Toshiba will probably keep supplying Apple with its hds in cunjuction with the introduction of its own brand of MP3 players... that way Toshiba is making money on both fronts. after all, it is better to have mutiple products of your own on the market to compete against each other than having just one of your own competing with all others...
lilteyang at 2007-11-15 15:05:15 >
[an error occurred while processing this directive]
[an error occurred while processing this directive]